Which is better for big messes?

The Brawny, because it offers a full sheet and is marketed as its strongest towel. The Sparkle tops out at a half sheet.

Which pack lasts longer?

The Sparkle pack has 12 double rolls against Brawny's 8, so it should last longer for the same household. Sparkle also lists 110 sheets per roll.

Is the Sparkle worth the extra?

At $14.67 at Amazon as of November 5, 2026, the Sparkle pack is cheap for 12 double rolls. Whether it costs more than the Brawny depends on the Brawny's current price, which was not given.

Are either of these compostable?

Sparkle states its towels are backyard and commercially compostable. Brawny does not state compostability for this product.

Which is better for small spills and kids?

Both offer a quarter sheet, which suits small spills and little hands. Sparkle names little hands as a typical user.

Do both have two plies?

Yes. Both are 2-ply perforated rolls with Tear-A-Square perforations.

Brawny Tear-A-Square Paper Towels vs Sparkle Tear-A-Square Paper Towels

Buy the Brawny Tear-A-Square 8 double-roll pack for a busy household that wants three sheet sizes and a strong towel for big messes. Buy the Sparkle Tear-A-Square 12 double-roll pack if you want more rolls and compostable, SFI-sourced paper at a low price. The Sparkle pack is $14.67 at Amazon as of November 5, 2026; no current price was given for the Brawny pack, so compare it at checkout before deciding.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.