Which is better for kitchen and pet messes?

The Brawny. Its 3-ply sheet resists tearing on wet counters, grease and pet accidents, and it costs less per pack at $10.58 at Amazon as of November 5, 2026.

Which one is better for composting?

The Sparkle. It is listed as backyard and commercially compostable and carries SFI Fiber Sourcing certification; the Brawny is neither compostable nor biodegradable.

Is the Sparkle worth the extra $4?

Only if compostability and certified fiber matter to you. Otherwise the Brawny gives you a thicker 3-ply sheet for less money.

Which has more sheet size options?

The Brawny. It tears into quarter, half and full sheets; the Sparkle offers quarter and half sheets only.

Are either of them scented?

No. Both are unscented white rolls with embossed texture.

Which lasts longer per roll?

Hard to say from the listings, since roll sizes are described differently. The Brawny's large rolls are stated as equal to two Brawny regular rolls; the Sparkle lists 110 sheets per roll and 100.8 sq ft per pack.

Brawny Tear-A-Square Paper Towels vs Sparkle Tear-A-Square Paper Towels

Buy the Brawny if you want the strongest sheet per dollar: 3-ply, quarter/half/full tear options, and $10.58 at Amazon as of November 5, 2026. Buy the Sparkle if compostability and a smaller footprint matter more than price, at $14.67 at Amazon as of November 5, 2026. The Brawny is about $4 cheaper and the heavier towel; the Sparkle is the greener one.

Today the Brawny Tear-A-Square Paper Towels costs $4.09 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.