Brazilian Joia Shampoo and Conditioner Set vs Pantene Shampoo and Conditioner Hydrating Glow, Sulfate-free with Baobab Essence, 9.6 fl oz + 8 fl oz

Buy the Brazilian Joia set if your hair is fine to medium, color-treated or damaged, and you want clinically measured repair: 58% damage repaired, 71% frizz reduction for 8 hours and 76% of split ends mended after one use. Buy the Pantene Hydrating Glow set if your hair is normal and mostly needs gentle, sulfate-free hydration and you prefer a lighter botanical scent. Brazilian Joia has the stronger repair and smoothing claims and the more talked-about Cheirosa 62 scent, but owners say the shampoo lathers poorly, so you use more product, and some complain the reformulation changed the color and texture. Pantene is the simpler, milder pick with fewer bold claims.

• Choose the Brazilian Joia set if you have fine to medium, dry or color-treated hair with frizz, split ends or damage and want a bonding-style repair duo with a strong gourmand scent.
• Choose the Pantene Hydrating Glow set if your hair is normal and you want a gentle, sulfate-free cleanse and hydration with a light botanical fragrance and no heavy feel.