Which is better for whipping cream?

Both have 5 speeds and will whip cream. The Black & Decker's 175 W motor and turbo boost give it more headroom for stiff peaks and larger batches.

The Black & Decker backs its mixer with a 2-year limited warranty; the Brentwood lists no warranty. Motor life depends on use, but the stronger 175 W motor is the safer bet for frequent mixing.

Is the Black & Decker worth the extra $1.20?

Yes for most shoppers. For about $1.20 more you get 25 more watts, turbo boost, a whisk and a 2-year warranty.

Can I put the beaters in the dishwasher?

The Brentwood's chrome-plated beaters are listed as dishwasher safe. The Black & Decker listing does not state dishwasher safety, so hand wash its beaters.

Which is lighter to hold?

The Brentwood is described as small and lightweight. The Black & Decker weighs 2.2 lb, which is noticeable during long mixing.

Do both handle cookie dough?

The Black & Decker is rated for heavy mixtures and is the better choice for thick dough. The 150 W Brentwood is better suited to eggs, cream and thin batter.

Brentwood HM-45 Hand Mixer vs Black & Decker Lightweight Hand Mixer

Buy the Brentwood HM-45 if you want the lowest price and a simple, light mixer for eggs, cream and thin batter. Buy the Black & Decker if you want more power, a turbo boost and a 2-year limited warranty. As of November 7, 2026, the Brentwood is $8.79 at The Ville Warehouse and the Black & Decker is $10.00 at Poshmark, so the gap is about $1.20.

Today the Brentwood HM-45 Hand Mixer costs $1.21 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.