Brooklinen Down Pillow vs Casper Original Pillow

Buy the Brooklinen Down Pillow if you want a traditional down pillow with real loft and a breathable cotton cambric shell. Buy the Casper Original Pillow if you want an all-foam pillow that holds its shape and needs no fluffing. Brooklinen uses 600+ fill power European white goose down in a medium firmness, so it feels soft and compresses under your head; owners praise the loft but note down needs shaking out and can trigger allergies despite the hypoallergenic claim. Casper's foam core is denser and more supportive for back and side sleepers, but it sleeps warmer and some owners find it too firm at first.

• Choose the Brooklinen Down Pillow if you want a soft, moldable down pillow with a breathable cotton shell and a medium feel.
• Choose the Casper Original Pillow if you want a foam pillow that keeps its shape and needs no fluffing.