Casper Original Pillow vs Utopia Bedding Bed Pillows

The Casper Original Pillow is a single, thick polyester pillow built for sleepers who want a tall, firm-feeling headrest; the Utopia Bedding pillows are a softer, gusseted pair aimed at budget-conscious shoppers who want a plush, cooling pillow. Casper's build is more substantial and its brand is better known for sleep products, but it is one pillow. Utopia's pair wins on value and versatility, though its soft fill and hand-wash-only care mean it will flatten sooner. Reviewers of Utopia praise the softness and cooling cover; Casper owners like the loft and support but some find it too tall.

• Choose the Casper Original Pillow if you want one tall, supportive polyester pillow and prefer a known sleep brand over a pair of softer pillows.
• Choose the Utopia Bedding Bed Pillows if you want a soft, gusseted pillow with a cooling cover and a two-pillow set suits your bed.