Brooks Addiction Walker 2 vs Hoka Bondi 8 Women's

Buy the Brooks Addiction Walker 2 if you need motion control for flat feet, a removable insole for orthotics, or a slip-resistant leather shoe for work. Buy the Hoka Bondi 8 Wide if you want the thickest, softest cushioning Hoka makes and a roomier forefoot for long days on your feet. The Brooks is the sturdier, more supportive shoe and the more consistent pick; the Bondi 8 is plusher and lighter-feeling underfoot but has a softer, less guided ride and a rocker that some wearers find unstable. Owners praise the Brooks for all-day support and the Bondi for cushioning, though both draw complaints about fit and durability.

• Choose the Brooks Addiction Walker 2 if you have flat feet or overpronate, wear orthotics, or need a leather walking shoe with a certified slip-resistant sole for work.
• Choose the Hoka Bondi 8 Wide if you want maximum cushioning and a wide, roomy fit for standing or walking long hours on hard surfaces.