Brooks Addiction Walker 2 vs New Balance 840v5 Walking Shoe

The Brooks Addiction Walker 2 is the better pick for women who need firm motion control and a leather upper that holds up to daily wear. The New Balance 840v5 is the better pick for anyone who needs an extra-wide fit or a lighter, breathable mesh shoe, and its PDAC approval matters if you are pursuing Medicare reimbursement. Reviewers of the Brooks praise the support and stability but note the shoe is heavy and stiff out of the box. The New Balance 840v5 is a softer, more flexible walker with a 12 mm drop.

• Choose the Brooks Addiction Walker 2 if you want maximum motion control for flat feet, a removable insole for orthotics, and a durable leather upper for everyday walking.
• Choose the New Balance 840v5 if you need an X-Wide (2E) fit, a breathable mesh upper, or a PDAC-approved style for possible Medicare reimbursement.