Brooks Cascadia 19 vs adidas Terrex Agravic GTX Trail Shoe

The Cascadia 19 is the better pick for most trail runners: it is lighter, has deeper lugs for loose and rocky ground, and owners consistently call it stable and comfortable over long days. The Terrex Agravic GTX wins on weather and road-to-trail versatility, with a GORE-TEX membrane, a gusseted tongue and Continental rubber. Build quality is solid on both, but the Cascadia's fit runs narrow and small for some buyers, so try it on or size up. Step up to the adidas only if wet weather and mixed surfaces matter more than pure trail grip.

• Choose the Brooks Cascadia 19 if you run technical, rocky or loose trails and want a light, stable shoe that stays comfortable for hours.
• Choose the adidas Terrex Agravic GTX if you run in rain, mud or wet grass and want a waterproof shoe that also handles pavement and easy paths.