Brooks Ghost 17 vs New Balance 1080 v15

The Ghost 17 is the safer pick for a woman who wants a familiar daily trainer with a 10 mm drop, broad width options and a firmer, more stable ride. The 1080 v15 is the softer, lighter shoe and suits men logging long easy miles who prefer a lower 6 mm drop. Owners praise the Ghost's cushioning and grip but some say the new upper runs narrow and pinches; the 1080's extra-soft Infinion foam wins on plushness, though its lower drop and softer platform suit fewer runners.

• Choose the Brooks Ghost 17 if you want a neutral daily trainer with a 10 mm drop, four width fittings and a more grounded, stable feel for runs, walks and the gym.
• Choose the New Balance 1080 v15 if you are a man who wants maximum softness and a lighter shoe for long easy runs and recovery days.