Which ring keeps ashes more secure?

The Hearbeingt ring. It uses a screw plus a rubber washer, while the Butterfly Ring relies on a screw and a drop of super glue on the threads.

Can I get either one engraved?

Yes. The Butterfly Ring engraves on the ring or a small tag, best at 5–10 characters. The Hearbeingt ring engraves on the pendant, but only on seller-fulfilled orders.

Does the Butterfly Ring come in other sizes?

The listing shows only size 9. The Hearbeingt listing does not state a ring size at all, so confirm before ordering.

Both are stainless steel, but the Hearbeingt ring specifies 316L, which resists tarnish and corrosion well. The Butterfly Ring's finish is plated rose/pink, which can wear over time.

Is the birthstone ring worth the extra?

If you want a birthstone and a washer-sealed chamber, yes. If you just want a simple keepsake at the lowest price, the Butterfly Ring covers that.

Butterfly Ring Cremation Jewelry for Ashes Keepsake Jewelry Urns Ring Memorial Jewelry Finger Ring vs Infinity 12 Birthstone Mini Ring Hold Loved Ones Ashes Cremation Urn Ring for Women Finger Ring Memorial Jewelry

Q: Which is cheaper?

The Butterfly Ring, at $14.21 at Walmart as of November 4, 2026. No price was given for the Hearbeingt ring.

Buy the Butterfly Ring if you want a low-cost, simple urn ring and don't need a birthstone. Buy the Hearbeingt Infinity ring if you want a birthstone accent and a 316L stainless steel build with a screw-and-washer seal. The Butterfly Ring is $14.21 at Walmart as of November 4, 2026; no price was given for the Hearbeingt ring.

Ask our shopping agent