Which is warmer for winter?

The Calvin Klein. It has insulated polyester fill rated medium weight and a faux-fur-lined collar and hood. The Eddie Bauer is a lightweight thermal layer built for fall.

Which is better for skiing?

The Calvin Klein. It is listed for skiing and cold weather with a water-resistant, wind-resistant shell. The Eddie Bauer Windfoil is aimed at everyday fall wear.

Is the Calvin Klein worth the extra over the Eddie Bauer?

There is barely any extra: $29.00 versus $29.99. The Calvin Klein adds insulation, a removable hood and more pockets for about a dollar less at its recent low.

Which fits taller men better?

The Eddie Bauer, which comes in Regular Tall. The Calvin Klein is regular fit only, and buyers disagree on whether it runs large or small.

Neither maker publishes a durability rating. The Calvin Klein uses a ripstop shell, which resists tearing, while the Eddie Bauer relies on a weather-resistant finish that can wear off with washing.

Can I wear the Eddie Bauer in cold winter weather?

Only as a mid-layer. It is lightweight with thermal fleece lining, so pair it with a shell for freezing temperatures.

Calvin Klein Men's Puffer Jacket vs Eddie Bauer Windfoil Thermal Jacket

Buy the Calvin Klein jacket for cold winter days, skiing, or a dressier casual look. Buy the Eddie Bauer Windfoil for a lighter, packable layer for fall and active everyday wear. Prices are close: the Calvin Klein hit a low of $29.00 on October 30, 2026, while the Eddie Bauer has sat at $29.99 since November 6, 2026. The Calvin Klein gives more warmth and features for about the same money, but its sizing complaints are real.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.