Which is warmer, the Tommy Hilfiger Ivy or the Eddie Bauer Windfoil?

The Eddie Bauer Windfoil. It is insulated with a thermal fleece lining, while the Tommy Hilfiger Ivy is an uninsulated lightweight jacket.

Is the Eddie Bauer Windfoil worth it over the Tommy Hilfiger?

At $29.99 as of November 6 versus $84.50 for the Tommy as of November 5, yes for warmth and weather protection. Pick the Tommy only if you want its relaxed cut and colors.

Which jacket is better for rain and wind?

The Eddie Bauer. It has a weather-resistant finish and a moisture-shedding fabric; the Tommy Hilfiger listing states no weather resistance.

Does the Eddie Bauer Windfoil come in tall sizes?

Yes. It is offered in Regular and Regular Tall, which the Tommy Hilfiger Ivy does not list.

Which is better for layering under a coat?

The Tommy Hilfiger Ivy, because it is uninsulated and lightweight. The Eddie Bauer's fleece lining adds bulk.

How long is the Eddie Bauer Windfoil?

It is hip length, 29 inches at center-back in size Medium.

Tommy Hilfiger Lightweight Ivy Jacket vs Eddie Bauer Windfoil Thermal Jacket

Buy the Eddie Bauer Windfoil Thermal if you want the most jacket for the money: it is insulated, weather-resistant and listed at $29.99 as of November 6, against $84.50 for the Tommy Hilfiger Ivy as of November 5. Choose the Tommy Hilfiger if you want a relaxed, lightweight layering piece in Sandalwood, Medium Red, Light Navy or National Forest and don't need insulation. The Eddie Bauer is the better value by a wide margin; the Tommy is the better style pick.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.