Calvin Klein Puffer & Quilted Jacket vs Perry Ellis Lightweight Hooded Puffer Jacket

The Perry Ellis Lightweight Hooded Puffer is the safer pick for most shoppers. It adds a removable hood, water-resistant fabric and stretch, and it holds a 4.6 average from nearly 3,000 ratings. The Calvin Klein jacket is a regular-fit quilted puffer with faux down fill, a stand-up collar and zip waist pockets, but it has no hood and is listed only in size XL in tan. Both are nylon shells with polyester fill; the Perry Ellis gives you more weather protection and more sizing room.

• Choose the Calvin Klein if you want the brand name, a clean stand-up collar look and a quilted tan jacket in size XL.
• Choose the Perry Ellis if you want a hood, water resistance and stretch for wet or windy days.