Calvin Klein Puffer & Quilted Jacket vs Don't Rain On My Puffer Jacket

The Calvin Klein is the sharper-looking jacket: quilted, stand-up collar, zip pockets, faux down, and a regular fit that layers well. The Don't Rain On My Puffer is the more practical everyday pick: it has a hood, a high neck, plus sizes, and three colorways, and it holds a 4.3 average from about 2,000 ratings. Buy the Calvin Klein for a cleaner streetwear look in tan; buy the other one if you want a hood and a wider size range.

• Choose the Calvin Klein if you want a quilted, stand-up-collar puffer with zip pockets and a regular fit that layers under a coat or over a sweater.
• Choose the Don't Rain On My Puffer if you want a hooded, high-neck puffer in black, chocolate or white, including plus sizes.