Which is warmer, the Collar Hooded or the Lined Hooded Puffer?

The Collar Hooded Puffer lists duck down and feather fill, which usually insulates better than the synthetic-style fill implied for the Lined Hooded Puffer. The Lined version is described by buyers as lightweight but well insulated, so it suits milder winters.

Which one should I buy if I layer sweaters underneath?

The Collar Hooded Puffer has a relaxed, longline fit and a two-way zip, which gives more room and flexibility for layering. The Lined Hooded Puffer runs true to size but has more complaints about tight sleeves and shoulders.

Is either coat worth the extra over the other?

They cost the same $39.96 at Macy's as of November 3, 2026, so there is no premium to pay. The Collar Hooded Puffer has more fill and a lower recent price, while the Lined Hooded Puffer is lighter and has more buyer ratings.

Which has the better hood?

Both have faux-fur hood trim. The Collar Hooded Puffer uses a faux-fur collar on the hood; the Lined Hooded Puffer has a faux-fur lined hood that some buyers find heavy and wish was detachable.

Which one holds up better over time?

The Collar Hooded Puffer's down fill and two-way zip are durable but need careful washing. The Lined Hooded Puffer has one report of broken stitching near the lower zipper, so check the seams when it arrives.

Which is the better deal right now?

The Collar Hooded Puffer is the better deal at the same price because it dropped to $30.00 on November 1, 2026, and is sold new at 4 stores versus 2 for the Lined Hooded Puffer.

Calvin Klein Women's Collar Hooded Puffer Coat vs Calvin Klein Women's Lined Hooded Puffer Coat

Both are Calvin Klein hooded puffer coats at the same $39.96 at Macy's as of November 3, 2026, so the price is a tie. The Collar Hooded Puffer is the better buy for most shoppers: it has down and feather fill, a two-way zip, and a recent low of $30.00 on November 1. The Lined Hooded Puffer is the pick if you want a lighter coat with a faux-fur lined hood and a simpler front zip.

Ask our shopping agent