Which is warmer, the Collar Hooded or the Packable Puffer?

The Collar Hooded Puffer. It uses duck down and feathers, which trap heat better than the quilted fill in the Packable. The Packable is fine for cold but not deep-winter cold.

Which coat is better for travel?

The Packable Puffer. It is built to pack down, while the Collar Hooded is a longline coat with a faux-fur hood trim that takes up more room.

Do both coats run small?

Buyers report sizing issues on both. The Collar Hooded gets mixed feedback, with some saying it runs small and others large. The Packable runs small for some shoppers, so check the size chart before ordering.

Is the Collar Hooded Puffer worth the extra over the Packable?

They cost the same right now, $39.96 at Macy's as of November 3, 2026. The Collar Hooded gives you down fill and a faux-fur hood for the same money, so it is the better value if you don't need packability.

How long are these coats?

Both are about 30 inches long, according to Macy's product pages. The Collar Hooded is described as a longline fit, so it sits a bit lower on the body.

Can I return the Packable Puffer if the size is wrong?

Check the listing before you buy. Buyers complain that some Packable Puffer sales are final sale, which means no return if the size is wrong.

Calvin Klein Women's Collar Hooded Puffer Coat vs Calvin Klein Women's Packable Puffer Coat

Both are about 30-inch Calvin Klein puffer coats with hoods, and both are cheap right now. The Collar Hooded Puffer is the warmer, more weather-ready coat, with a down-and-feather fill and a faux-fur hood trim, at $39.96 at Macy's as of November 3, 2026. The Packable Puffer is the lighter, more packable option and has far more buyer feedback, at $39.96 at Macy's as of November 3, 2026. Buy the Collar Hooded for real winter cold and the Packable for travel and milder days.

Ask our shopping agent