Calvin Klein Women's Puffer Jacket vs Alva Womens Waterproof Trench Coat

Buy the Calvin Klein puffer if you want a warm, lightweight, packable layer for cold dry days and prefer a relaxed fit with a full lining. Buy the Alva trench if rain and wind are your main problem, you want a hood, and you need a size above 18. The puffer is a simple quilted polyester jacket with a stand collar and a 26.5-inch length; owners call it warm, soft and well made, but some report a sticky zipper and mixed sizing. The Alva is a taped-seam, waterproof, windproof trench with a removable hood and toggle waist, rated higher by far more owners, though it runs roomy and the hood can be oversized.

• Choose the Calvin Klein puffer if you want a warm, machine-washable everyday layer for cold, mostly dry weather and a relaxed fit that leaves room for a sweater.
• Choose the Alva trench if you face rain and wind, want a removable hood and a waist you can cinch, or need a size above 18.