Which is warmer for a cold winter?

The Calvin Klein puffer, on its own. Its insulated fill and stand collar are built for cold dry days. The Summit keeps you dry and blocks wind, but its fleece liner is lighter than a down-style puffer.

Is the Summit worth the extra $47?

Yes if you get rained or snowed on. The 5,000 mm waterproof shell, removable hood and three wearing modes are things the Calvin Klein cannot do. If you only need warmth on dry days, save the money.

Which is better for skiing or hiking?

The Summit. It is designed for active cold-weather use, with a waterproof shell, adjustable cuffs, a removable hood and four secure pockets. The Calvin Klein puffer is a casual street coat.

Both are 100% polyester. The Calvin Klein is machine washable, which is easier on a coat you wear daily. The Summit needs hand washing, and its waterproof coating wears with time and washing.

Does either run small?

Calvin Klein buyers disagree: some say it runs large, others small, so try it on or check the size chart. Summit tells you to check the size guide and leave room for layers.

Can I wear the Summit in mild weather?

Yes. Wear the shell alone in rain or the fleece liner alone on cool dry days. The Calvin Klein puffer is a single layer, so it is too warm for mild weather.

Calvin Klein Women's Stand Collar Lined Puffer Jacket vs Summit 3-in-1 Waterproof Jacket - Women's

Buy the Calvin Klein puffer if you want a warm, dressy everyday winter coat at a very low price: $39.96 at Macy's as of November 3, 2026. Buy the Summit 3-in-1 if you need rain and snow protection and want one jacket for three seasons: $86.99. The Summit costs about $47 more, and that premium buys waterproofing and a removable fleece liner, not more warmth.

Ask our shopping agent