Canada Goose MacMillan Puffer Jacket vs 686 Hydra Thermagraph Jacket

The Mac Millan is the warmer, dressier jacket: 625-fill down, a hip-length parka cut and a fur-free hood make it the one for cold city winters and everyday wear. The 686 Hydra Thermagraph is a snowboard shell with 20K/20K waterproofing and breathability, taped seams and underarm vents, so it wins for skiing, riding and wet snow. Reviewers of the Canada Goose praise the warmth and build but call it heavy and stiff; 686 owners rate the weather protection and pocket layout, though the 140g insulation is lighter than down for standing around in deep cold.

• Choose the Canada Goose Mac Millan if you want maximum warmth for cold, dry city winters and a clean parka look you can wear over a sweater or suit.
• Choose the 686 Hydra Thermagraph if you ride, ski or spend time in wet snow and need real waterproofing, breathability and venting.