Canada Goose MacMillan Puffer Jacket vs Mountain Hardwear First Tracks Jacket

The Mac Millan is the warmer, more urban jacket: heavyweight down, a hip-length cut and a two-way zip make it the better pick for cold city winters and everyday wear. The First Tracks is the better mountain and wet-weather jacket: waterproof Dry.Q fabric, underarm vents, a helmet-compatible hood and a RECCO reflector. Reviewers rate Canada Goose down warmth and build highly but note the bulk and the brand premium; Mountain Hardwear owners praise the First Tracks as a versatile ski and storm shell, though at 80 g body insulation it is a mid-weight insulator, not a deep-cold down piece.

• Choose the Canada Goose Mac Millan if you want maximum down warmth for cold city winters and a clean, casual hip-length look.
• Choose the Mountain Hardwear First Tracks if you ski, ride or hike in wet snow and need a waterproof shell with vents, a helmet hood and a RECCO reflector.