Which is better for a deep mattress?

The Cannon. Its pocket fits mattresses up to 18 inches deep. The Eddie Bauer fits up to 12 inches, so it will not work on a thick mattress or topper.

Which set lasts longer?

Both are 200 thread count single-weave cotton percale, so wear should be similar. The Eddie Bauer lists durable, tightly woven, single-ply construction; the Cannon lists no durability claims. Its higher rating from more than twice as many ratings is the better signal.

Is the Eddie Bauer worth the extra?

It is not extra right now. At $38.86 as of November 4 it is cheaper than the Cannon at $45.49 as of October 31, and it is rated higher.

Are these the same fabric?

Yes, both are 200 thread count cotton percale. The Eddie Bauer is single-ply and tightly woven; the Cannon does not specify ply.

Which is better for hot sleepers?

Both are breathable cotton percale. The Eddie Bauer explicitly lists breathable and lightweight, so it is the safer pick if you sleep hot.

Do both come as 4-piece sets?

Yes, both are 4-piece sets and both are machine washable.

Cannon Solid Percale Sheet Set vs Eddie Bauer Camp Cotton Sheet Set

Buy the Eddie Bauer Camp Cotton if your mattress is 12 inches deep or less and you want the better-reviewed, cheaper sheet. It is $38.86 as of November 4, down from $53.70 on October 31. Buy the Cannon Solid Percale only if you need an 18-inch deep pocket, and expect to pay $45.49 as of October 31.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.