Which is warmer, the Carhartt or the Heat Holders?

The Heat Holders is the warmer pick on paper. It carries a 4.4 TOG rating and uses HeatWeaver lining plus Thinsulate, while Carhartt publishes no warmth rating for its insulated glove.

Which glove is better for shoveling or working outdoors?

The Carhartt. Its digital-grip palm and stick-grip fingers hold tools and handles better, and it comes in sizes up to 2XL.

Is the Carhartt worth $5 more?

Yes if you need grip and durability for work. No if you mainly want warmth for walking or commuting, where the Heat Holders costs less and rates warmer.

Do both gloves keep hands dry?

Yes. Carhartt uses a waterproof insert and Heat Holders uses a windproof and waterproof shell. Neither is a fully sealed winter mountaineering glove.

How do the sizes compare?

Carhartt runs S to 2XL. Heat Holders offers only S/M and is listed as a women's fit, so larger hands may not fit.

Carhartt Insulated Waterproof Gloves vs Heat Holders High Performance Winter Gloves

Buy the Carhartt if you need a work glove that grips tools and holds up to wet, cold jobs. Buy the Heat Holders if you want maximum warmth for light wear like commuting or walking. The Heat Holders is cheaper at $29.99 at Walmart as of November 7, 2026, against $34.99 at Amazon for the Carhartt.

Today the Heat Holders High Performance Winter Gloves costs $5.00 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.