Carhartt Duck Insulated Bib Overalls vs RefrigiWear Extreme Softshell Bib Overalls

Buy the RefrigiWear Extreme Softshell Bib if you work in serious cold or wet conditions; its -60°F comfort rating, waterproof zippered pocket and padded knees beat the Carhartt on weather protection. Buy the Carhartt Duck Insulated Bib for general cold-weather work where abrasion resistance and a proven duck canvas matter more than extreme temperature ratings. The Carhartt is the tougher, more familiar workwear build; the RefrigiWear is the warmer, more weather-sealed option, and owners rate it slightly higher.

• Choose the Carhartt Duck Insulated Bib if you want a rugged 12-ounce cotton duck bib for cold days on the job and value Cordura-reinforced kick panels and knee-pad compatibility over extreme cold ratings.
• Choose the RefrigiWear Extreme Softshell Bib if you work in subzero or wet conditions and need a -60°F comfort rating, waterproof pockets and padded knees.