Berne Icecap Insulated Bib Overall vs RefrigiWear Extreme Softshell Bib Overalls

Both are rated 4.8, but they solve cold differently. The Icecap is a heavy 1,000-denier nylon shell with a waterproof, wind-resistant finish and triple-needle seams, built for wet, abrasive outdoor work. The RefrigiWear Extreme Softshell is a softer, stretchier bib with a -60°F comfort rating, padded knees and fleece-lined pockets, aimed at brutal dry cold. Owners of the Icecap call it extremely warm and dry but stiff at first and small on some; RefrigiWear's larger review base backs its warmth and comfort.

• Choose the Icecap if you work in wet snow, rain or mud and need a tough waterproof shell that shrugs off abrasion.
• Choose the RefrigiWear Extreme Softshell if you face deep dry cold and want padded knees, fleece pockets and easier movement.