Carianna Oversized Chair vs Brogliano Oversized Chair

Both are 54-inch oversized chairs built on the same platform foundation, with top-grain leather on the seating areas and matched faux leather elsewhere. The Carianna is the better pick for most people: it is 4 inches shallower, 31 lbs lighter, has roll arms with nailhead trim, and carries a 5-out-of-5 rating from 14 owners. The Brogliano is deeper and heavier, with a plainer casual look and no owner rating to judge it by.

• Choose the Carianna if you want a transitional chair with nailhead trim, a shallower footprint that fits more rooms, and a track record of strong owner ratings.
• Choose the Brogliano if you want a deeper, more casual chair in a brown espresso finish and don't need the decorative detailing.