Are these the same chair?

Yes. The dimensions, weight, materials and cushion construction match. They are two listings of the same Signature Design by Ashley Carianna chair.

Which is better for a small living room?

Both take the same floor space at 54 inches wide and 40 inches deep. Neither is compact. Measure your room and your 36-inch doorway before ordering either.

They should wear the same. The platform foundation is built to resist sagging better than sinuous springs, and the corner-blocked frame is solid. The leather is top-grain with a protective finish.

Is the leather real all over?

No. Genuine top-grain leather covers the seat, back and arm cushions. Matched faux leather covers the remaining outside areas.

Is it worth stepping up to a full sofa?

Only if you regularly seat two people. This chair seats one adult comfortably with room to spare, and a sofa adds width and weight you may not have space for.

How firm is the seat?

Firm. High-resiliency foam wrapped in poly fiber holds its shape but does not sink much. Owners who like a soft, deep chair should sit in one first.

Carianna Oversized Chair vs Ashley Carianna Chair and a Half

These are the same chair sold under two names. The dimensions, weight, leather, cushions and platform foundation all match, so the choice comes down to the listing, not the product. Owners rate both highly, and the Carianna line is known for a firm seat and a tight, wrinkle-free look that holds up better than sinuous springs. Buy whichever listing has the color and delivery terms you want.

Choose the Carianna Oversized Chair if you want the listing that spells out the platform foundation and corner-blocked frame in detail.
Choose the Carianna Chair and A Half if you prefer the listing that notes the reinforced frame and natural hide variation.

Prices

Carianna Oversized Chair: $788.00 at Adams Furniture (last seen Nov 10)
Ashley Carianna Chair and a Half: $899.99 at Tony's Home Furnishings (last seen Nov 10)
Difference: the Carianna Oversized Chair is $111.99 cheaper than the Ashley Carianna Chair and a Half at the latest prices (Nov 10)

	Carianna Oversized Chair	Ashley Carianna Chair and a Half
Overall size	54"W x 40"D x 40"H	54"W x 40"D x 40"H
Seat and arm dimensions	Seat 23" deep, 22" high; arms 28" high, 32" apart	Same seat and arm figures
Weight	109 lbs	109 lbs
Upholstery	Top-grain leather with wax pull-up crackle; matched faux leather on outside areas	Same leather and faux leather mix
Frame and support	Corner-blocked frame; platform foundation resists sagging 3x better than springs after 20,000 cycles	Reinforced frame; same platform-style support described
Cushions	Loose seat cushions, attached back, high-resiliency foam wrapped in poly fiber	Loose seat cushions, attached back, high-resiliency foam wrapped in poly fiber
Included pillow	One 24" toss pillow with feather-fiber blend	Accent pillow with feather-fiber blend
Delivery clearance	36" minimum doorway width	36" minimum doorway width

Spec	Carianna Oversized Chair	Ashley Carianna Chair and a Half
Arm height	28"	28"
Distance between arms	32"	32"
Seat depth	23"	23"
Seat height	22"	22"
Leg height	3"	3"
Minimum doorway width	36"	36"
Accent pillow size	24"	24"
Width	54"	—
Height	40"	—
Depth	40"	—
Weight	109.00 lbs (49.44 kgs)	—
Overall width	—	54.0in

Spec	Carianna Oversized Chair	Ashley Carianna Chair and a Half
Overall depth	—	40.0in
Overall height	—	40.0in
Product weight	—	109.0 lb
Cushion to back height	—	18"

Carianna Oversized Chair vs Ashley Carianna Chair and a Half

Prices

Carianna Oversized Chair vs Ashley Carianna Chair and a Half

Prices

Ashley Carianna Chair and a Half

What separates them

Price history

Prices at every store