Carolina Herrera Good Girl 3-Piece Set 2.7oz Women EDP Spray vs Carolina Herrera Good Girl 6-Piece Coffret Set
Buy the 3-Piece Set if you want one full bottle of Good Girl to wear daily. Buy the 6-Piece Coffret if you want to try the whole Good Girl line before committing to a full bottle. The 3-Piece Set is the better value per ounce of actual perfume; the Coffret gives variety but only about 0.3 fl oz total.
Ask our shopping agent
Carolina Herrera Good Girl 3-Piece Set 2.7oz Women EDP Spray
Choose the 3-Piece Set if you already know you like original Good Girl and want a 2.7 oz bottle plus a hair mist and a purse spray.
Pros
- Full 2.7 oz EDP is the main event, not a sample
- Hair mist and 0.34 oz purse spray add value
- Original Good Girl is a proven amber floral with cocoa and tonka
- Straightforward gift for someone who already wears Good Girl
Cons
- Only one scent, so no variety
- No travel minis of the other Good Girl variants
- Heavy bottle is not ideal for a bag
What separates them
| Carolina Herrera Good Girl 3-Piece Set 2.7oz Women EDP Spray | Carolina Herrera Good Girl 6-Piece Coffret Set | |
|---|---|---|
| Total fragrance volume | 2.7 oz EDP plus 0.34 oz EDP plus 1 oz hair mist | Six 0.05 fl oz (1.5 ml) minis, about 0.3 fl oz total |
| Scent range | Original Good Girl only | Six variants: Good Girl, Very Good Girl, Very Good Girl Glam, Blush, Blush Elixir, Very Elixir |
| Format | Full-size bottle, purse spray and hair mist | Mini spray vials only |
| Best use | Daily wear and gifting a known favorite | Discovery and travel |
| Refill or repurchase path | Full bottle lasts months; easy to rebuy the same scent | Minis run out in a few wears; you still need to buy a full bottle |
| Packaging | Gift box with three pieces | Boxed set, but reviewers say vials are hard to remove and only partly full |
| Fragrance family |
Price history
- Carolina Herrera Good Girl 3-Piece Set 2.7oz Women EDP Spray: lowest $147.90 on Oct 30 at Macy's.
- Carolina Herrera Good Girl 6-Piece Coffret Set: lowest $25.00 on Oct 30 at Mercari.
Prices at every store
Carolina Herrera Good Girl 3-Piece Set 2.7oz Women EDP Spray
- Devora HouseCheck price at Devora House
- AmazonCheck price at Amazon
- Macy'sCheck price at Macy's
Carolina Herrera Good Girl 6-Piece Coffret Set
- eBayCheck price at eBay
- MercariCheck price at Mercari
Specs compared
| Spec | Carolina Herrera Good Girl 3-Piece Set 2.7oz Women EDP Spray | Carolina Herrera Good Girl 6-Piece Coffret Set |
|---|---|---|
| Department | Women's | Women's |
| Fragrance Family | Ambery Floral | — |
| Top Notes | Almond | — |
| Middle Notes | Tuberose, Jasmine Sambac | — |
| Bottom Notes | Roasted Tonka Bean, Cocoa | — |
| Type | — | Eau de Parfum |
| Set | — | Yes |
| Gifts For Mothers | — | Yes |
| Travel Size | — | Yes |
Questions and answers
- Which is better for daily wear?
- The 3-Piece Set. Its 2.7 oz EDP is a full bottle that lasts months of regular use, while the Coffret minis run out in a few wears each.
- Which should I buy if I have never tried Good Girl?
- The 6-Piece Coffret. It lets you test the original plus Very Good Girl, Blush and the Elixirs before spending on a full bottle.
- Is the 6-Piece Coffret worth it for the price?
- Only as a sampler. You get about 0.3 fl oz of perfume total, so the cost per ounce is much higher than the 3-Piece Set's full bottle.
- Do the minis in the Coffret spray well?
- They are 1.5 ml spray vials. Reviewers say they work but are small, only partly full and awkward to pull from the packaging.
- Which lasts longer on skin?
- The original Good Girl EDP in the 3-Piece Set is an amber floral with tonka and cocoa that wears for hours. The Elixir variants in the Coffret are parfum strength and generally last as long or longer.
- Is either set a good gift?
- Both are gift-boxed. The 3-Piece Set suits someone who already wears Good Girl; the Coffret suits someone who wants to explore the line.