Carolina Herrera Good Girl 6-Piece Coffret Set vs Carolina Herrera set
Buy the 6-piece coffret if you want to try the whole Good Girl line before committing to a full bottle. Buy the 2-piece duo if you already know you like Good Girl and Good Girl Blush and want larger minis of just those two. The 6-piece set spreads 9 ml across six scents; the duo gives 14 ml across two.
Ask our shopping agent
Carolina Herrera Good Girl 6-Piece Coffret Set
Choose the 6-piece coffret if you want to sample Very Good Girl, Blush Elixir, Very Elixir and Glam alongside the originals before buying a full bottle.
Pros
- Six different Good Girl scents in one box
- Covers the original plus five flankers and elixirs
- Boxed set works as a gift
- Small vials fit a bag or carry-on
Cons
- 1.5 ml vials give only a few wears each
- Vials are reported partly full and hard to pull from the packaging
- No full-size bottle included
What separates them
| Carolina Herrera Good Girl 6-Piece Coffret Set | Carolina Herrera set | |
|---|---|---|
| Number of scents | 6 (Very Good Girl, Blush, Very Good Girl Glam, Good Girl, Blush Elixir, Very Elixir) | 2 (Good Girl EDP, Good Girl Blush Parfum) |
| Volume per vial | 1.5 ml (0.05 fl oz) | 7 ml per bottle |
| Total fragrance | 9 ml across six vials | 14 ml across two bottles |
| Concentration | Eau de parfum and parfum | Eau de parfum |
| Scent range | Original, flankers and elixirs | Original and Blush only |
| Packaging | Boxed set; vials reported hard to remove and only partly full | Two mini bottles in a box |
| Best use | Discovery and gifting | Travel and repeat wear of two known scents |
Price history
- Carolina Herrera Good Girl 6-Piece Coffret Set: lowest $25.00 on Oct 30 at Mercari.
- Carolina Herrera set: lowest $39.95 on Oct 30 at eBay.
Prices at every store
Carolina Herrera Good Girl 6-Piece Coffret Set
- eBayCheck price at eBay
- MercariCheck price at Mercari
Carolina Herrera set
- AmazonCheck price at Amazon
- eBayCheck price at eBay
- Kohl'sCheck price at Kohl's
Specs compared
| Spec | Carolina Herrera Good Girl 6-Piece Coffret Set | Carolina Herrera set |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Eau de Parfum | Set, Perfume Set |
| Department | Women's | Women's |
| Set | Yes | — |
| Gifts For Mothers | Yes | — |
| Travel Size | Yes | — |
| Size | — | 7 ml |
| Application Type | — | Perfume |
| Form | — | Spray |
| Scented | — | Yes |
| Scent Notes | — | Tonka bean, Almond, Cocoa, Jasmine |
| Variety | — | Good Girl Blush |
Questions and answers
- Which set is better for trying the Good Girl line?
- The 6-piece coffret. It includes the original, Blush, Very Good Girl, Glam, Blush Elixir and Very Elixir, so you can compare the whole range before buying a full bottle.
- Which gives more fragrance for the money?
- The 2-piece duo, at 14 ml total versus 9 ml in the coffret. The coffret's value is variety, not volume.
- Are the coffret vials big enough to judge a scent?
- Barely. At 1.5 ml each you get a few wears per scent, and buyers report the vials arrive only partly full. Enough to decide if you like a scent, not enough to wear it regularly.
- Is Good Girl Blush the same in both sets?
- No. The duo lists Blush as a parfum; the coffret includes Good Girl Blush in eau de parfum and Blush Elixir separately. Parfum is the stronger, denser version.
- Which is the better gift?
- The 6-piece coffret. A boxed six-scent set reads as a more complete gift, and the recipient can pick a favorite. The duo suits someone who already wears Good Girl.
- Can I layer the scents?
- Yes. The duo is listed as layerable, and the coffret's original and elixir versions layer well together. Test on skin before committing to a combination.