StoreDeal.ai store
Shop
  • Deals
  • Deal checker
  • Black Friday
  • Buying guides
  • Brands
  • Stores
Travel
  • Flight deals
  • Hotel deals
Company
  • Research
  • Press
  • deal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026
  • Walmart
  • Best Buy
  • Target
  • TVs
  • Laptops
  • Headphones
  • Apple
  • Gaming
  • Vacuums
  • Kitchen
  • Toys
  • Smartwatches
  • Tablets
  • Furniture
  • Mattresses
© Deal.ai Inc.
TermsPrivacy
Deal.ai › Compare

Caron Cinnamon Swirl Cakes Yarn vs Lily Sugar'n Cream Cotton Cone Yarn

Buy the Caron Cinnamon Swirl Cakes for soft, warm garments and blankets you want to wash and dry without fuss. Buy the Lily Sugar'n Cream cone for dishcloths, potholders, market bags and afghans that need cotton's absorbency and durability. Caron is plied acrylic with a soft hand and good drape for shawls and cardigans; Sugar'n Cream is a firm, absorbent cotton that holds stitch definition and gets softer with washing. Owners of both praise easy care, but cotton cones can split and show wear faster in high-friction use, while acrylic pills and can feel warm against skin.

  • Choose the Caron Cinnamon Swirl Cakes if you want a soft, machine-washable worsted acrylic for garments, shawls and blankets, and you like working from a large self-striping cake.
  • Choose the Lily Sugar'n Cream cone if you need absorbent, durable cotton for dishcloths, potholders, bags and home decor, and you want one continuous cone for big projects.

Prices

  • Caron Cinnamon Swirl Cakes Yarn: $12.50 at Etsy (checked today)
  • Lily Sugar'n Cream Cotton Cone Yarn: $17.99 at Amazon (last seen Nov 9)
  • Difference: the Caron Cinnamon Swirl Cakes Yarn is $5.49 cheaper than the Lily Sugar'n Cream Cotton Cone Yarn at the latest prices (Nov 9 and Nov 10)
Caron
Caron Cinnamon Swirl Cakes Yarn - Retailer Exclusive

Caron Cinnamon Swirl Cakes Yarn

Caron Cinnamon Swirl Cakes Yarn - Retailer Exclusive

5(1 rating)
$12.50at EtsyChecked 7 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit Etsy
Pros
  • Soft hand suits garments and blankets
  • Large 407-yard cake means fewer joins
  • Self-striping colorways add interest without color changes
  • Machine washable and dryable
  • Worsted gauge works with common US 8 needles and H hook
Cons
  • Acrylic pills with friction
  • Low absorbency, poor for dishcloths
  • Can feel warm and clammy against skin
  • Retailer exclusive and only sold in the US and Canada
Lily Sugar'n Cream
Lily Sugar'n Cream 14 oz 100% Cotton Cone Black Yarn

Lily Sugar'n Cream Cotton Cone Yarn

Lily Sugar'n Cream 14 oz 100% Cotton Cone Black Yarn

4.8(1,324 ratings)
$17.99at AmazonChecked Nov 9
See all prices and details
Visit Amazon

As an Amazon Associate, Deal.ai earns from qualifying purchases.

Pros
  • Absorbent cotton suits kitchen and bath projects
  • Firm twist holds stitch definition
  • Large cone gives a long continuous length
  • Wide shade range including neutrals and brights
  • Machine washable and dryable
Cons
  • Cotton can split while working
  • Less drape for shawls and garments
  • Heavier cone is awkward to store and carry
  • Black and dark shades can fade with repeated washing

What separates them

Caron Cinnamon Swirl Cakes YarnLily Sugar'n Cream Cotton Cone Yarn
Fiber100% acrylic100% USA-grown cotton
Hand and drapeSoft and supple, drapes well for shawls and cardigansFirm and crisp, holds stitch definition
AbsorbencyLow absorbency, not ideal for dishclothsHighly absorbent, suited to kitchen textiles
Put-up8 oz cake, 407 yards, center-pull14.1 oz cone, long continuous length
Color rangeSelf-striping swirl colorways, retailer exclusiveSolid shades including neutrals, brights and pastels
CareMachine wash and tumble dryMachine wash and dry
Gauge17 sts x 22 rows = 4 in on US 8 needlesWorsted weight, standard medium gauge
Durability in heavy useAcrylic pills with frictionCotton stands up to repeated washing

Price history

$17.99$11.24
Nov 4Nov 11
  • Caron Cinnamon Swirl Cakes Yarn: lowest $11.24 on Nov 10 at Michaels Stores.
  • Lily Sugar'n Cream Cotton Cone Yarn: lowest $14.99 on Nov 4 at Ben Franklin; $14.99 on Nov 11.

Prices at every store

Caron Cinnamon Swirl Cakes Yarn

  • EtsyNew

    In stockSold by CraftiqueRedux

    $12.50Free shippingChecked 7 h ago
    Visit Etsy
  • JMR Legacy Crochet Designs & SuppliesNew

    In stock

    $12.95Checked 7 h ago
    Visit JMR Legacy Crochet Designs & Supplies
  • eBayNew

    In stockSold by cfleak

    $12.99+ $4.85 shippingChecked 7 h ago
    Visit eBay
  • Michaels StoresNew

    In stock

    $11.24+ $8.95 shippingChecked 7 h ago
    Visit Michaels Stores

Also available at

  • YarnspirationsCheck price at Yarnspirations

Store links may earn us a commission.

All 8 stores and price history →

Lily Sugar'n Cream Cotton Cone Yarn

  • WalmartNew

    In stock

    $17.99+ $5.99 shippingChecked 2 h ago
    Visit Walmart
  • AmazonNew

    Availability unknown

    As an Amazon Associate, Deal.ai earns from qualifying purchases.

    $17.99Checked Nov 9
    Visit Amazon
  • WalmartNew

    Availability unknown

    $17.99Checked Nov 4
    Visit Walmart
  • Craft WarehouseNew

    Availability unknown

    $18.97Checked Nov 4
    Visit Craft Warehouse

Also available at

  • Ben FranklinCheck price at Ben Franklin
All 8 stores and price history →

Specs compared

SpecCaron Cinnamon Swirl Cakes YarnLily Sugar'n Cream Cotton Cone Yarn
Fiber content100% acrylicCotton
Yarn weight#4 Worsted—
Yardage407 yards—
Cake weight8-ounce—
Caremachine washable and tumble dry friendly—
Ball size454 g/16 oz, 372 m/407 yds—
Gauge#4 Worsted (Medium)—
color—Black
shape—Black
actual_color—Black
multipack_quantity—1
size—x 26
Show all 17 specsShow fewer specs
SpecCaron Cinnamon Swirl Cakes YarnLily Sugar'n Cream Cotton Cone Yarn
Thickness—Medium Weight
Fiber—Cotton
Shade—Purple Haze, Faded Denim, Teal
Theme—Orchid, Mistletoe
Weight—14.1 oz

What reviewers say

Caron Cinnamon Swirl Cakes Yarn

Owners like the generous yardage and easy care for blankets and home projects. Many praise the soft feel for an acrylic and the smooth, even stitch definition. Some find it squeaky on the hook and note that stripe lengths and dye lots can vary.

What people mention
  • YardagePraisedOwners like that one cake covers a lot of ground, cutting down on joins in blankets.
  • SoftnessPraisedMany say it feels softer than expected for a 100% acrylic yarn.
  • CarePraisedMachine washing and drying is a common reason people choose it for gifts and home items.
  • SqueakCriticisedSome crocheters find the acrylic squeaky against metal hooks.

Lily Sugar'n Cream Cotton Cone Yarn

  • 4.8 / 51,324 ratings

Buyers rate this cone highly, with 4.8 out of 5 across 1,324 ratings. They like the absorbent cotton for dishcloths and the convenience of a large cone. Complaints center on stiffness and the bulk of the cone.

What people mention
  • Cotton absorbencyPraisedOwners say the cotton absorbs water well, which suits dishcloths and towels.
  • Cone sizePraisedBuyers like getting a long continuous strand with few joins from the 14 oz cone.
  • StiffnessMixedSome find the cotton stiff to work with at first but softer after washing.

Questions and answers

Which is better for dishcloths and potholders?
The Lily Sugar'n Cream cone. Cotton absorbs water and handles heat, and it holds up to repeated washing. Acrylic like Caron is not absorbent and can melt against a hot pan.
Which is better for a cardigan or shawl?
The Caron Cinnamon Swirl Cakes. Its acrylic has a softer hand and more drape, which suits garments and wraps. Cotton is firmer and heavier for those projects.
Which lasts longer?
It depends on use. Cotton resists pilling and takes repeated washing well in kitchen textiles. Acrylic holds color and shape but pills with friction, so both last years with normal care.
Is the Caron cake enough for a blanket?
One 407-yard cake makes a small baby blanket or a shawl. A full throw needs several cakes, so plan the colorway lots before starting.
Can I use the same hook or needle size for both?
Both are worsted weight, so US 8 needles and a 5 mm H hook work for each. Swatch anyway, because cotton and acrylic behave differently.
Is one worth stepping up to?
Step up to the Sugar'n Cream cone if you want one long continuous length for big cotton projects and fewer joins. Stay with Caron if softness and drape matter more than absorbency.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

More comparisons

  • Peaches & Creme Cone 4 Medium Cotton Yarn, White 14oz/400g, 674 Yards vs Lily Sugar'n Cream 14 oz 100% Cotton Cone Black Yarn
  • Caron Cinnamon Swirl Cakes Yarn - Retailer Exclusive vs Peaches & Creme Cone #4 Medium Cotton Yarn, White 14oz/400g, 674 Yards (3 Pack)
  • Peaches & Creme Cone 4 Medium Cotton Yarn, White 14oz/400g, 674 Yards vs Caron Cinnamon Swirl Cakes Yarn - Retailer Exclusive

Buying guides that pick them

  • Best yarn for electric knitting machines
  • WashabilityPraisedReviewers report it survives machine washing and drying without falling apart.