Which is better for dishcloths?

Both work well because both are worsted-weight 100% cotton. Pick the Lily Sugar'n Cream black cone if you want to hide stains, or the Peaches & Crème white cone if you want to bleach or dye them.

Is the Peaches & Crème cone worth the savings?

Yes if you want white cotton. At $12.00 at Walmart as of November 4, 2026, it costs $2.99 less than the Lily cone and gives 674 yards.

Which yarn lasts longer?

Both are 100% cotton of similar weight, so durability is close. The Lily cone states machine washable and dryable care, which helps it hold up through repeated washing.

Can I use them together in one project?

Yes. Both are medium worsted-weight cotton, so they work at the same gauge. A white and black pair suits striped dishcloths, potholders or afghans.

The Peaches & Crème cone lists 674 yards at 14 oz. The Lily cone is 14.1 oz but does not state yardage, so the difference is small.

Which do shoppers rate higher?

Lily Sugar'n Cream rates 4.8 out of 5 from 1,324 ratings; Peaches & Crème rates 4.7 out of 5 from 3,598 ratings. The gap is tiny.

Peaches & Creme Cone 4 Medium Cotton Yarn, White 14oz/400g, 674 Yards vs Lily Sugar'n Cream 14 oz 100% Cotton Cone Black Yarn

Both are 14 oz cones of worsted-weight 100% cotton, so the real choice comes down to color and price. The Peaches & Crème cone in White is $12.00 at Walmart as of November 4, 2026, about $3 less than the Lily Sugar'n Cream cone in Black at $14.99 at Ben Franklin as of the same date. Buy Peaches & Crème for white dishcloths, washcloths and afghans at the lower price. Buy Lily Sugar'n Cream if you need black cotton and prefer its slightly higher rating.

Today the Peaches & Creme Cone 4 Medium Cotton Yarn, White 14oz/400g, 674 Yards costs $0.71 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.