Which is better for standing all day?

The Skechers Workshire has a Memory Foam insole and Relaxed Fit, which most people find softer out of the box. The CAT Second Shift has a removable PU liner and buyers often add their own insole for more cushioning.

The CAT Second Shift has the edge. Its Goodyear welt construction can be resoled, and the full grain leather upper and steel shank are built for years of hard use. The Skechers uses a cemented synthetic outsole that is harder to repair.

Is the CAT worth the extra $5?

Yes if you want resoleable construction, a heat rating and electrical hazard protection. No if comfort out of the box and the lowest price matter more, since the Skechers is $77.00 at Footwear outlet as of November 3, 2026.

Are either of them waterproof?

Neither is fully waterproof. The CAT Second Shift is not waterproof at all. The Skechers Workshire is water-resistant, which handles light rain and damp ground but not standing water.

Which is better for wide feet?

The Skechers Workshire. Its Relaxed Fit gives extra room through the toe box and instep. The CAT Second Shift comes in standard width only.

Do both meet safety toe standards?

Yes. The CAT meets ASTM F2413-11 I/75 C/75 for impact and compression. The Skechers meets EN ISO 20345 SB FO SRA, which also covers impact and compression plus slip resistance.

CAT Men's Second Shift 6" Steel Toe Boot vs Skechers Work Workshire Relaxed Fit Steel Toe Boot

Buy the CAT Second Shift if you want a proven, widely reviewed steel toe boot with Goodyear welt construction and electrical hazard rating. Buy the Skechers Workshire if you want a lighter-feeling, cushioned boot at the lowest price. The Skechers is $77.00 at Footwear outlet as of November 3, 2026, about $5 less than the CAT at $82.17 at Amazon as of the same date.

Today the Skechers Work Workshire Relaxed Fit Steel Toe Boot costs $5.17 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent