Which is better for wet weather?

The Rocky Worksmart. It has guaranteed waterproof construction and an insulated upper. The CAT Second Shift is not waterproof at all.

Which toe is safer, composite or steel?

Both meet ASTM F2413 impact and compression standards, so protection is comparable. Composite is lighter and does not conduct cold; steel is the traditional choice and the CAT is rated to 572 °F.

The CAT has the longer public track record, with 18,507 ratings at 4.4 out of 5, and its Goodyear welt can be resoled. The Rocky has too few ratings to judge long-term wear.

Is the CAT worth saving about $7?

Only if you work dry jobs. At $82.17 versus $89.00 on November 3, 2026, the saving is small, and the Rocky adds waterproofing, insulation and less weight.

Which is better for cold work?

The Rocky Worksmart, which is insulated and waterproof. The CAT has no insulation.

Which is lighter on long shifts?

The Rocky at 1.65 lb per boot versus the CAT at 2.00 lb, both size 10M. That is about 0.35 lb less per foot.

Rocky Men's Worksmart Waterproof Composite Toe Work Boot vs CAT Men's Second Shift 6" Steel Toe Boot

Buy the Rocky Worksmart if you work in wet or cold conditions: it is waterproof, insulated, composite-toed and EH rated, and it costs $89.00 at Cowpokes Work and Western as of November 3, 2026. Buy the CAT Second Shift if you want a proven, widely rated steel-toe boot for dry indoor or fair-weather work, at $82.17 at Amazon as of November 3, 2026. The CAT is about $7 cheaper and far better reviewed, but it is not waterproof. The Rocky has sold near $79.88 as recently as November 1, 2026, so its price moves.

Today the CAT Men's Second Shift 6" Steel Toe Boot costs $6.83 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent