Caterpillar Second Shift Steel Toe Work Boot vs Carolina Amped Composite Toe Wedge Boot

Buy the Carolina Amped if you work on concrete, scaffolding or in wet weather: the composite toe is lighter, the boot is waterproof, and the 8-inch wedge sole spreads load and can be resoled. Buy the Caterpillar Second Shift if you want a lighter-duty, lower-cut steel-toe boot for general site work and don't need waterproofing. Reviewers of the Cat praise its durable Goodyear welt and comfortable break-in but note it is not water resistant and the steel toe is heavier. Carolina owners report the wedge sole is stable and the AG8 footbed is comfortable for long shifts, though the boot is bulkier and the composite toe gives less crush protection than steel.

• Choose the Caterpillar Second Shift if you want a 6-inch steel-toe boot for dry general construction and prefer a lower, lighter cut.
• Choose the Carolina Amped if you stand on concrete all day, work in wet conditions, or want a resoleable 8-inch wedge boot with a composite toe.