Caterpillar Second Shift Steel Toe Work Boot vs Georgia Boot Amplitude Work Boot

The Second Shift is the tougher, longer-lasting boot: Goodyear welt construction, a steel shank and a steel toe make it a classic jobsite boot that resoles and holds up. The Amplitude is the comfort pick: waterproof full-grain leather, a composite ERGO-FIT toe and a memory foam insole that molds to the foot. Owners rate the Amplitude around 3.5 out of 5, with comfort praised and fit and width complaints common; the Second Shift is a plain, stiff break-in boot that many wearers keep for years.

• Choose the Cat Second Shift if you want a resoleable, heavy-duty leather boot with a steel toe and steel shank for hard jobsite wear.
• Choose the Georgia Amplitude if you work in wet or muddy conditions and want a waterproof composite-toe boot with a cushioned memory foam insole.