Which is better for two large cats?

The Nature's Miracle. Its extra-large 26 by 23 inch footprint and corner shape give two big cats more room, and the non-stick surface speeds up scooping.

Which is easier to clean?

The Catit Jumbo, because the hood lifts up instead of coming off. The Nature's Miracle hood must be removed to scoop, though its non-stick surface resists caking.

Which controls odor better?

The Nature's Miracle on paper. It combines a charcoal filter that lasts up to three months with antimicrobial plastic that resists odor absorption. The Catit relies on a carbon filter alone.

Is the Catit Jumbo big enough for a Maine Coon?

It is marketed for large cats, but Catit does not list dimensions here. Measure your cat and compare against the Nature's Miracle's 26 by 23 by 20 inches before buying.

Do both need filter replacements?

Yes. Both use carbon or charcoal filters that you replace. Nature's Miracle says its filter lasts up to three months; Catit sells replacements separately without a stated interval.

Which is better for a cat that kicks litter out?

The Catit Jumbo. Its hood and removable door contain scatter better, and reviewers specifically warn the Nature's Miracle is not good for cats that throw litter.

Catit Jumbo Hooded Litter Pan vs Nature's Miracle Hooded Corner Multi-Cat Litter Box with Charcoal Filter, X-Large

Buy the Nature's Miracle if your cats are large or you have more than one and you want a corner box with a non-stick surface and antimicrobial plastic. Buy the Catit Jumbo if you want a hood that lifts up for scooping and a built-in bag anchor, and you don't mind a box that sits flat against a wall. No current prices were provided for either box, so check both on Deal.ai before deciding.

Ask our shopping agent