Which is better for a large cat?

Both are sold as extra-large boxes. The Van Ness Extra-Giant pairs its size with a wider entry door, which helps a big cat get in and out. The Catit Jumbo is marketed for large cats and multi-cat homes but lists no door width.

Which controls odor better?

Both use replaceable filters. The Van Ness includes zeolite filters in the box; the Catit carbon filters are sold separately, so budget for refills. The Van Ness also adds a drip shield that helps keep urine from leaking between the top and bottom.

Is the Catit worth choosing over the Van Ness?

Only if the lift-up hood and bag anchor matter to you. The Van Ness has far more ratings (3,110 versus 1) and a much higher score (4.2 versus 3.0), so it is the safer pick for most shoppers.

Which is easier to clean?

The Catit hood lifts up for full access, which helps on deep cleans. The Van Ness has a smooth interior with no hard-to-reach corners and a high-polish finish, which helps on daily scooping.

Do both come with filters?

The Van Ness includes filters. The Catit uses replaceable carbon filters that are sold separately, so add that cost over time.

Neither maker states a lifespan. The Van Ness is BPA-free plastic made in the USA and has a large base of long-term user ratings; the Catit has almost no rating history to judge durability.

Catit Jumbo Hooded Litter Pan vs Van Ness Covered Cat Litter Box, Extra-Giant

Buy the Van Ness Extra-Giant for most shoppers. It has a 4.2 rating from 3,110 ratings, a wider entry door, a drip shield and included filters. The Catit Jumbo is the pick only if you want a hood that lifts fully off for cleaning and a built-in bag anchor. No current price was given for either box, so compare live store prices before you buy.

Ask our shopping agent