Cinch Stone 1/2 Zip Pullover vs Carhartt Paxton Quarter-Zip Hoodie

The Cinch Stone 1/2 Zip is the dressier pick: a cable-knit textured pullover with a stand-up mock collar, Metaluxe zipper and leather logo patch, cut in a classic fit from a stretch polyester-spandex blend. The Carhartt Paxton is the tougher, roomier option: a loose-fit cotton-poly fleece hoodie with a drawstring hood, pockets, water-repellent finish and sizes up to 4XL. Owners of quarter-zips in this style tend to praise the Cinch for looking sharp at the office or under a jacket, while Carhartt buyers value the Paxton for hard wear and layering over work clothes. Buy the Cinch for a cleaner Western look; buy the Carhartt for warmth, coverage and durability.

• Choose the Cinch Stone 1/2 Zip if you want a smart-casual pullover with a mock neck and cable texture that works for office days and nights out.
• Choose the Carhartt Paxton if you want a loose, hooded fleece layer with pockets and a water-repellent finish for cold, dirty or wet work.