Cinch Stone 1/2 Zip Pullover vs Polo Ralph Lauren Luxury Jersey Quarter Zip

The Polo Ralph Lauren is the better pick for most shoppers: a cotton-rich jersey knit that breathes and drapes like a sweater, with the pony logo and a regular fit that works under a blazer or over a tee. The Cinch is the more rugged, technical layer, with a polyester-spandex cable knit, a stand-up mock neck and a Metaluxe zipper built for outdoor wear. Build quality is close, but owners of cotton jersey quarter-zips report softer hand-feel and easier care, while the Cinch's synthetic blend resists wrinkles and holds shape through repeated washing.

• Choose the Cinch Stone 1/2 Zip if you want a textured Western-style layer for cool-weather outdoor wear and prefer a stretch synthetic that shrugs off wrinkles.
• Choose the Polo Ralph Lauren Luxury Jersey Quarter Zip if you want a soft cotton-blend sweater that dresses up for the office and feels natural against the skin.