Which is warmer, the Wooden Ships or the Paul Fredrick?

The Paul Fredrick is 100% cotton, while the Wooden Ships description lists 40% acrylic. Acrylic adds warmth, so the Wooden Ships may feel warmer, but the fiber label is inconsistent.

Is the Paul Fredrick worth $80 more?

Only if you need tall sizes, a plain look, or a sweater you can machine wash. Otherwise the Wooden Ships at $59.00 covers the same holiday use for less.

Which one lasts longer?

The Paul Fredrick has a clearer care routine and all-cotton knit, which usually holds up well. The Wooden Ships blend with acrylic can pill with wear.

Can I machine wash either sweater?

The Paul Fredrick says machine wash cold, lay flat to dry. The Wooden Ships lists no care instructions, so hand wash or follow the hang tag.

Does either come in tall sizes?

Only the Paul Fredrick. It comes in regular and tall. The Wooden Ships comes in standard sizes only.

Which is better for an office holiday party?

The Paul Fredrick's plain pattern is the safer choice for a work setting. The Wooden Ships MERRY lettering and tree patches are more casual.

Wooden Ships Merry Embroidered Crew vs Cotton Christmas Crew Neck Sweater

Buy the Wooden Ships Merry Embroidered Crew if you want a playful holiday sweater at a low price. It is $59.00 at Sudies as of November 8, 2026, versus $139.00 at Paul Fredrick for the Paul Fredrick Cotton Christmas Crew Neck. The Paul Fredrick is the better pick if you want a plain, machine-washable 100% cotton crew in regular or tall sizes.

Today the Wooden Ships Merry Embroidered Crew costs $80.00 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.