Which is better for everyday winter wear?

The Paul Fredrick sweater. It is a plain 100% cotton crew neck you can machine wash and wear past the holidays. The Mariah Carey sweater is a white Fair Isle holiday piece that needs hand washing.

Is the Mariah Carey sweater worth the savings?

Yes, if you want a holiday sweater and want to spend little. At $44.95 at Teba as of November 8, 2026, it costs about $94 less than the $139.00 Paul Fredrick sweater.

Which one is easier to care for?

The Paul Fredrick. Turn it inside out, machine wash cold, and lay it flat to dry. The Mariah Carey sweater is hand wash only.

Does either come in tall sizes?

Only the Paul Fredrick. It comes in regular and tall. The Mariah Carey sweater is regular fit only.

Which fits a holiday party better?

The Mariah Carey sweater, with its white Fair Isle pattern. The Paul Fredrick is a festive Christmas pattern too, but it reads as a standard crew neck pullover.

Which has more stretch?

The Mariah Carey sweater, which has 1% spandex and medium stretch. The Paul Fredrick is 100% cotton with no added stretch.

Cotton Christmas Crew Neck Sweater vs Mariah Carey All I Want For Christmas Sweater

Buy the Mariah Carey sweater if you want a festive Fair Isle pullover at a low price; it is $44.95 at Teba as of November 8, 2026. Buy the Paul Fredrick cotton crew neck if you want a plain, machine-washable 100% cotton sweater in regular or tall sizes; it is $139.00 at Paul Fredrick as of November 8, 2026. The Mariah Carey costs about $94 less, but it needs hand washing and its listing is tied to a 2023–24 holiday run.

Today the Mariah Carey All I Want For Christmas Sweater costs $94.05 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.