Coach Brooklyn Shoulder Bag vs Coach Brooklyn 28 Shoulder Bag

Both are the same Coach Brooklyn hobo in natural grain leather, so the real choice is size. The Brooklyn (11.5" long, 8.75" tall) is the smaller, more compact bag; the Brooklyn 28 (11" long, 11" tall) is taller and holds more vertically. Owners praise the soft leather, wide 10.5"-drop strap and magnetic snap on both, and the main complaints are that neither fits a laptop and that the leather can wrinkle. Buy the Brooklyn 28 if you carry more day to day; buy the smaller Brooklyn if you want a lighter, tidier bag.

• Choose the Coach Brooklyn if you want the more compact hobo that sits close to the body and still holds phone, wallet, keys and a notebook.
• Choose the Coach Brooklyn 28 if you want more vertical room for daily essentials and prefer the taller silhouette.