Coach Brooklyn Shoulder Bag vs Coach Soft Tabby Shoulder Bag

The Soft Tabby is the better all-round pick for most shoppers: a structured flap bag with a zip pocket outside, a removable crossbody strap and a higher owner rating, though from a much smaller sample. The Brooklyn is the softer, roomier hobo, and owners praise its wide strap and slouchy leather, but several question the leather quality and note it will not hold a laptop despite some listings claiming otherwise. Buy the Brooklyn for a relaxed everyday shoulder bag; buy the Soft Tabby if you want a bag that works crossbody and keeps small items zipped away.

• Choose the Brooklyn Shoulder Bag if you want a soft, slouchy hobo that sits comfortably on the shoulder and swallows daily essentials without feeling bulky.
• Choose the Soft Tabby if you want a structured bag with a flap closure, an outside zip pocket and a detachable strap for crossbody wear.