Coach Soft Tabby Shoulder Bag vs Kate Spade Knott Large Tote

The Coach Soft Tabby is the better pick if you want a structured crossbody that works day to night. Its denim-and-leather build, gold hardware and 21.5-inch strap drop give it more range than the Knott Large Tote. The Knott is the roomier bag: it fits a 15-inch laptop and A4 paper, and its pebbled leather is easy to wipe clean. Owners rate both highly, and the Tabby's 4.8 from 23 ratings is a slightly larger sample than the Knott's 4.9 from 13.

• Choose the Coach Soft Tabby if you want a compact, structured crossbody with a long adjustable strap and a top handle for dressier days.
• Choose the Knott Large Tote if you need to carry a laptop, paperwork or a full day's gear and prefer a tote you can also sling over your shoulder.