Columbia Newton Nimble vs Oboz Sawtooth Ascent Low Hiking Shoe

The Oboz Sawtooth Ascent Low is the stronger pick for most hikers. It pairs a Vibram XS-Trek EVO outsole and a B-DRY waterproof membrane with LWG gold-standard suede, and owners consistently praise the out-of-box comfort, fit and traction. The Columbia Newton Nimble is lighter on structure, with water resistance rather than a true membrane and Omni-Grip rubber instead of Vibram. Choose the Columbia if you want a low, flexible leather shoe for light trails and mixed climbing use.

• Choose the Columbia Newton Nimble if you want a low-cut leather trail shoe with cushioned, shock-absorbing construction for light hikes and everyday wear.
• Choose the Oboz Sawtooth Ascent Low if you want a waterproof suede hiker with a Vibram outsole, a supportive O-Fit insole and a rolled collar that owners say feels good from day one.