HOKA Anacapa 2 Freedom vs Columbia Newton Nimble

The HOKA Anacapa 2 Freedom is the more comfortable, more sustainable shoe, with a plush sugarcane EVA midsole, a Vibram Megagrip outsole and a slip-on heel that flexes for easy entry. The Columbia Newton Nimble is the simpler, more traditional pick, with a lugged Omni-Grip outsole, lace closure and water-resistant leather. Owners praise the HOKA's cushioning and easy on-off for long days, while the Columbia suits hikers who want a lighter, lower, lace-up shoe for moderate trails.

• Choose the HOKA Anacapa 2 Freedom if you want maximum cushioning, a grippy Vibram outsole and slip-on convenience for long or mixed-terrain hikes.
• Choose the Columbia Newton Nimble if you prefer a lighter, low-cut lace-up shoe with water-resistant leather for day hikes and trekking.