Columbia Women's Amaze Puff Mid Hooded Jacket vs Donna Karan New York Belted Hooded Puffer Coat

Buy the Columbia Amaze Puff Mid if you want a warm, weather-ready everyday puffer with a removable hood, thumbholes and a two-way zipper. Buy the Donna Karan belted puffer if you want a dressier thigh-length coat that cinches at the waist for a more shaped silhouette. The Columbia is the more technical jacket: 650-fill RDS down, Omni-Shield water and stain repellency, and a thigh-length cut rated for maximum warmth. The Donna Karan is the more fashion-forward coat, with a belt and detachable hood, but its listing gives fewer performance details, so treat it as a style pick rather than a weather piece.

• Choose the Columbia Amaze Puff Mid if you want a warm, water-resistant down puffer for cold, damp days and everyday wear.
• Choose the Donna Karan belted puffer if you want a thigh-length coat with a waist-defining belt and a more polished look.