lululemon Wunder Puff Jacket vs Columbia Women's Amaze Puff Mid Hooded Jacket

Both are warm down puffers with removable hoods and water-repellent shells. The lululemon Wunder Puff wins on styling and fit control: its cinchable waist and hem let you shape the coat, and the snug interior cuffs and long hem seal out drafts. The Columbia Amaze Puff Mid is the more practical cold-weather build, with 650-fill down, a thigh-length cut, a two-way zipper and thumbholes. Owners report the Wunder Puff runs tight through the shoulders, so size up if you layer heavily.

• Choose the Wunder Puff if you want a shaped, casual puffer you can cinch at the waist and wear over sweaters, and you value the lululemon fit and finish.
• Choose the Amaze Puff Mid if you want maximum warmth for everyday winter wear, a longer thigh-length cut, a two-way zipper and thumbholes.