Corky's Red Plaid Heads Up Sneakers vs Keds Center 3 Lace Up Sneaker

The Corky's Heads Up is the bolder, more decorative pick: a tartan plaid upper with white leather stripes and rhinestone laces, on a cushioned EVA footbed and gum rubber outsole. The Keds Center 3 is the quieter, more practical shoe: soft leather, a BlissFoam footbed, a slip-on hidden-gore entry and machine washability. Reviewers of the Corky's call it cute, comfortable and true to size; Keds owners praise first-wear comfort but several report stitching rips and color bleeding when wet. Buy the Corky's for a statement look, the Keds for easy everyday wear you can clean.

• Choose the Corky's Heads Up if you want a plaid statement sneaker with rhinestone laces and a cushioned, true-to-size fit.
• Choose the Keds Center 3 if you want a soft leather slip-on you can machine wash and wear for miles.