Corky's Red Plaid Heads Up Sneakers vs Nike Dunk Low Tartan Plaid

The Nike Dunk Low Tartan Plaid is the better-built shoe: leather upper, foam insole, padded low-cut collar and a rubber outsole with the hoops pivot circle. The Corky's Red Plaid Heads Up is the softer, lighter option with a cushioned EVA footbed and rhinestone laces, and owners call it very comfortable and true to size. Pick the Dunk for durability and a known fit you can size down for; pick the Corky's for a lighter, more decorative plaid sneaker.

• Choose the Corky's Red Plaid Heads Up if you want a lightweight, cushioned low-top with rhinestone laces and a gum sole, and you prefer a fit that runs true to size.
• Choose the Nike Dunk Low Tartan Plaid if you want a leather upper, a foam insole and a sturdier rubber outsole, and you are fine ordering half a size down.